Man City fans reacted to the guilty verdict on 114 of 115 charges with shock first and defiance soon after. The club denies wrongdoing and has appealed, and no punishment has been decided, so many supporters say they are waiting for the appeal before drawing conclusions.
Man City fans reacted to the guilty verdict on 114 of 115 charges with shock first and defiance soon after. The club denies wrongdoing and has appealed, and no punishment has been decided, so many supporters say they are waiting for the appeal before drawing conclusions.
What Man City fans said when the verdict landed
The verdict was reported on 25 September, and an official Premier League statement followed, Sports Illustrated reported. A BBC report carried by Yahoo Sports gathered early reaction. David Mooney of the Blue Moon podcast said he felt stunned and argued that fans are "just as much the victims" if the club is guilty. A season ticket holder named John, who went to the 2023 Champions League final in Istanbul, said that memory "will never be taken away".
David Wilson told the BBC that the memories of the trophies cannot be taken away and that true City fans will still love the club. Another fan, Matt, recalled being there when Paul Dickov scored in Division Two and joked about wanting to see Erling Haaland score a hat-trick against Grimsby, a nod to City's lower-division past.
Why many City supporters are waiting for the appeal
Not everyone is sure how to feel. Kevin Parker, general secretary of the Official Supporters Club, told Read Man City that the findings were hard to read, that he was troubled by the repeated use of the word "sham", and that he wondered where he goes from here as a City fan. He also said he expects "the majority will wait" and listen. Dickov joined him on a pub visit in Bredbury days after the verdict, which had been arranged months earlier.
The 1894 Group, a City supporters' group, took a similar line. Express and Star reported that many fans question whether the process was impartial and do not want to reach conclusions before the appeal. The group also said supporters do not need anyone telling them how to respond.
How the defiance showed at Anfield and the Etihad
City won 3-0 at Liverpool in their first league match after the verdict. Fans brought inflatable bananas, and an away-end banner read "In Khaldoon we trust", a reference to chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak, according to Sports Illustrated. The yellow stands came back for the home game against Ipswich on 17 October, when the 1894 Group said the display was fans responding in their own way.
What could happen to City next
No sanction has been announced. The BBC report listed a points deduction, fines or removal from the league as possible outcomes, and Al Jazeera noted that a heavy points deduction could lead to relegation, with speculation about the three titles won between 2009 and 2018. That is speculation until a panel decides. The appeal goes to a three-person panel, and the regulator's chair, David Kogan, said people expect a hearing in the middle or end of January.
Follow Man City on OneX2
See Man City's next fixtures on the OneX2 match list. Read the current offers on the promotions page before you deposit. As of 21 October 2026, it lists a 100% new member bonus (5,000 to 50,000 kyat, 10x turnover) and a 10% daily bonus (5x turnover).
Frequently asked questions
How did Man City fans react to the guilty verdict?
With shock at first, then defiance. Many say they will wait for the appeal, and others showed support with bananas and banners at Anfield and the Etihad.
Will Man City be relegated?
No sanction has been announced. Relegation has been raised in coverage as a possible result of a heavy points deduction, but City have appealed and the penalty is undecided.
When will the Man City appeal be heard?
It is expected in the middle or end of January, according to the regulator's chair, David Kogan.
Have Man City been stripped of titles?
No. Speculation about the 2009 to 2018 titles has appeared in the media, but no sanction has been announced.
Why did City fans bring bananas?
The bananas are a throwback to City's 1980s and 1990s fan culture and have come to symbolise defiance, Express and Star reported.